Sports
NFL
Seattle Seahawks

Malcolm Butler Defends Russell Wilson's Fateful Pick Years Later

Trend GatherTrend Gather
3 min read
100 trending
February 11, 2026
www.reddit.com
Malcolm Butler Defends Russell Wilson's Fateful Pick Years Later

Malcolm Butler Defends Russell Wilson's Fateful Pick Years Later

www.reddit.com

Russell Wilson's infamous pick in a 2015 game against the Carolina Panthers has been a topic of discussion for many years. The Seahawks quarterback's decision to attempt a Hail Mary pass in the end zone was widely criticized, and many felt that he should have taken a safer option. However, in a recent interview with The Seattle Times, former Patriots cornerback Malcolm Butler expressed his support for Wilson's decision, stating that he "made the right call."

Butler's comments are significant, given his own experience playing in high-pressure situations during his time with the Patriots. The former cornerback was a key member of the Patriots' defense during their Super Bowl XLIX victory and has a deep understanding of what it takes to succeed in the NFL.

Butler's Perspective on the Play

According to Butler, Wilson's decision to take the risk and attempt the Hail Mary pass was a calculated one. "Russell Wilson made the right decision," Butler said. "He knew the clock was running out, and he had to take a chance. It was a high-risk, high-reward play, and unfortunately, it didn't work out for him."

Butler's comments suggest that he believes Wilson's decision was motivated by a desire to win the game, rather than a lack of judgment or experience. This perspective is likely to resonate with Seahawks fans, who have long been loyal to their quarterback.

The Impact of the Play on the Game

The 2015 game between the Seahawks and Panthers was a pivotal one, with the Panthers ultimately emerging victorious. However, the game's outcome was far from certain, with the Seahawks trailing by just a few points with only a few minutes remaining. Wilson's decision to attempt the Hail Mary pass was a turning point in the game, and one that ultimately cost the Seahawks the win.

The impact of the play was felt far beyond the 2015 season, as well. The Seahawks' loss to the Panthers marked a turning point in the team's season, and one that ultimately contributed to their eventual exit from the playoffs.

Butler's Take on the Legacy of the Play

Butler's comments on Wilson's decision are significant, given the ongoing debate about the play's legacy. While some have criticized Wilson for his decision, others have praised him for his willingness to take risks and go for the win. Butler's perspective falls somewhere in between, suggesting that Wilson's decision was a calculated one that ultimately didn't pay off.

Ultimately, the legacy of Wilson's Hail Mary pass will continue to be debated among NFL fans and analysts for years to come. However, Butler's comments provide a fresh perspective on the play, one that suggests that Wilson's decision was motivated by a desire to win, rather than a lack of judgment or experience.

As the debate about the play continues to rage on, one thing is clear: Russell Wilson's decision to attempt the Hail Mary pass in 2015 will always be remembered as a pivotal moment in the NFL's history. Whether or not it was the right call remains a matter of opinion, but one thing is certain: it will continue to be discussed for years to come.

This article was generated with AI assistance and may contain errors. Readers are encouraged to verify information independently.

Related Articles